Are You Making Enough Money to be A Good Christian?

Face turning red, eyes narrowing, the older man said, “You’re not a real Christian if you don’t live up to your potential. The more money you make the more you can give.”

After our dinner conversation, I reflected on the man’s statement and other things said during dinner. I said to Ellen, “Preferred flavor or essential ingredient?”

She said, “What?”

“Tonight’s conversation made me think about our faith and how much we confuse preferred flavors with essential ingredients.”

I enjoy baking homemade bread. Let me amend that statement. I enjoy eating homemade bread. I figured out a few years ago that, if I waited for Ellen to make it, I’d have a long wait.

Ellen gets credit for this beautiful loaf of banana bread.

I could whine. I could beg. I could say all kinds of encouraging words like, “I sure love when you make homemade bread. You’re really good at it. No wonder your family heritage includes a successful bakery. It seems to be in your genes. You’re a natural. You’re great.”

Still no lovely smell of baking bread in our home.

Then one day I said, “Hey, I can follow a recipe and bake bread in the bread machine.” And I began to bake my ever-loving hind end off.

Here’re the essential ingredients in baking bread.





That pretty much sums it up. I better double check my recipe book.

Slap on head. I forgot water (or milk). How could I have forgotten water? That’s essential!

Everything else becomes preferences—whole wheat vs. white flour, molasses or honey vs. pure cane sugar, barley, flax seed, raisins, etc. Once I’ve got the basics down I can get creative. And Ellen would tell you that I do get creative.

So what about the essentials of our faith versus the preferences?

You tell me…

Choruses or hymns?

NIV, KJV, NKJV, NASB (just in case you’re wondering, those are not government programs but Bible versions, although they may also be government programs)?

Altar calls or choral benediction?

Beards or clean-shaven?

Suits, dresses, jeans, or t-shirts?

The Four Spiritual Laws?

Christian radio?

Focus on the Family?

Crosses or tattoos that say “I love Jesus”?

The list can be endless.

Earlier I made a list of essential ingredients for making bread. After making the list, I consulted a recipe book which reminded me that I’d forgotten one essential ingredient.

When I’m confused about the essentials of the Christian faith, I do have somewhere I can turn. Here are some basic questions that can help guide me.

1)      What does the Bible say? This isn’t the only question I can ask but it serves as a bookend. What do I mean by that? This is the one that I begin and end with. It’s foundational to our faith to know what the scriptures say.

2)      What is historically true of our faith? Councils have met periodically throughout history to determine the basics of the Christian faith. We see this even in Scripture itself when Christian leaders like Paul, James, and Peter addressed the issues facing the early church (see Acts 15). The historical creeds guide us in our understanding of God, Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit, and the Church.

3)      What counsel do mature people of faith offer? I recently read the story of Reheboam taking over the kingdom reins from his father King Solomon. In the early days of his reign, he had a decision to make. He consulted the elders then he consulted his young companions. He opted to follow the latter’s advice. The result? The kingdom split (sounds like a few churches I know). I may prefer what my pals say about an issue but I better seek the counsel of the mature. By the way, gray hairs tend to mark maturity but not always. Listen and observe. You’ll know who the wise are (they’re usually listening and observing).

4)      What does experience suggest? From the beginning, I must engage my mind and add my own life experiences to recognize God’s truth and faith’s essentials. Scripture cautions me to “not lean on [my] own understanding” but I don’t believe that means to ignore it altogether.

I’m curious. What do you believe are the Christian faith’s essential ingredients? What preferences have you seen become more than preferences within a church?

Something worth thinking about:

Jon Acuff’s “The R-word.”

Chris Patton’s “Why Do Business From An Eternal Perspective?”

Top 3 posts the last 7 days:

When We Invite People Into Community, What Are We Wanting Them to Experience?

3 Truths to Remember When Life Gets Unsettling

My Novel, “Dark Eyes, Deep Eyes,” Debuts

You can find Dark Eyes, Deep Eyes at:

WestBow Press

Barnes & Noble

“Dark Eyes, Deep Eyes” goes to the library as book tours city sites.

If you enjoyed today’s post, consider subscribing. Each new post will come directly to your email inbox. In a typical week, I post two new articles. Scroll up and you’ll find the Email Subscription button at the bottom of the right-hand column.

About tnealtarver

I've traveled and spoken around the world but always love to come home. There I eat exceptional meals, drink coffee to my heart's content, and get loved like nowhere else on earth. I believe a community centered in Christ should be all that and so much more.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Are You Making Enough Money to be A Good Christian?

  1. Kari Scare says:

    This is a really cool analogy. There are so many spats in church over preferences, and I believe getting hung up on preferences is one reason people church shop so much. We need what my pastor calls “broad shoulders” and not get so hung up on preference. If we continue to look to always have our preferences satisfied, we will never actually be content.

    • tnealtarver says:

      Your comments touch on something I’m still working out in my own thoughts. How do we get “big shoulders” and move beyond our preferences? That’s easier for me to say than do, but your point about trying to satisfy our own preferences never satisfying rings true. “Seek ye first” comes to mind as to how we should orient ourselves in church.

      • You’ve got me thinking about how I have developed broad shoulders over the years. I am thinking that through because I think it’s important somehow for me to understand the how. Some days they are broader than others, I know that already. Focusing on meeting needs rather than having needs met is part of it too. I’ve used the term a lot, but I have not thought much about how it happens.

        On another note, if you get a minute, check out my “How to… Pray for Others” post today. A discussion we had a while back is mentioned in the post.

  2. tnealtarver says:

    Kari, I checked it out ( ) and thought it was straightforward, honest, and helpful.

  3. Pingback: Do You Love People and Use Things or Love Things and Use People? | A Curious Band of Others

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s